Witches Brew Halloween Cake Jars Recipe

Hey friend, if you’re itching to make something truly magical and festive this Halloween, then you’re going to absolutely adore this Witches Brew Halloween Cake Jars Recipe. It’s not just a treat, it’s a whole spooky spectacle in a jar—layers of rich black cocoa cake, bright green buttercream, and those whimsical witchy fondant legs that just steal the show! Trust me, once you try this, these jars become the centerpiece at every Halloween party, and you’ll want to make them year after year.

this …

Ingredients You’ll Need

All the ingredients come together to build this spooky delight—from the luscious black cocoa cake to the vibrant green buttercream and the fun fondant accents. Here’s what you need, plus some handy tips on why each is essential to perfecting this recipe.

• Self-raising flour: This keeps the cake wonderfully light and rises beautifully without the fuss of separate leavening.
• Granulated sugar: Sweetens the cake just right and helps with a tender crumb.
• Butter: I recommend salted for the frosting to add depth and richness, but unsalted is fine for the cake itself.
• Eggs: They bind everything, and I always use room temperature eggs to help the cake rise evenly.
• Unsweetened black cocoa powder: The secret for that deep, almost eerie dark color and intense chocolate flavor.
• Baking powder: Makes sure the cake is fluffy, not dense.
• Salt: Just a pinch balances the sweetness and enhances flavor.
• Milk: Adds moisture and keeps the cake soft; any regular milk you have works perfectly.
• Vanilla extract: Brings warmth and rounds out the flavors in both cake and frosting.
• Powdered sugar (icing sugar): For that silky smooth buttercream without any grit.
• Electric green food coloring: This makes the frosting look like a bubbling witch’s brew—you only need a few drops!
• Orange and black fondant: For sculpting the iconic witch legs and shoes—this is where your creativity shines!
• CMC powder: This little trick keeps your fondant from getting sticky and helps your legs dry nice and firm.
• Sprinkles: Adds that extra festive sparkle and fills in the jars with playful color.

Variations

I love how versatile this recipe is—you can really make it your own depending on your tastes or dietary needs. Don’t be shy, mix it up or simplify as you like!

• Gluten-Free: When I tried swapping self-raising flour for a 1:1 gluten-free blend, the cake turned out just as moist, so feel free to customize for gluten sensitivity.
• Dairy-Free Buttercream: You can easily replace butter with coconut oil and use powdered sugar to whip up a dairy-free green buttercream—still creamy and festive.
• Different Flavors: I once added a hint of cinnamon to the cake batter for a spiced twist that paired amazingly with the chocolate and green frosting.
• Simple Decoration: If fondant isn’t your thing, piping green and orange buttercream “legs” or using gummy candy can be a fun alternative.

How to Make Witches Brew Halloween Cake Jars Recipe

Step 1: Craft the Witches’ Black and Orange Fondant Legs

Okay, this is where the magic begins and the fondant witch legs take shape! Knead a little CMC powder into the orange fondant until it’s soft and pliable—you’ll notice it’s easier to work with and won’t stick to your fingers as much. Roll the fondant into thin strips about 5mm in diameter, then cut into 10 cm lengths—you want 18 legs for your jars. Keep these covered while you work so they don’t dry out. Next, roll black fondant into thinner strips about 2-3mm to make the stripes. Use a damp brush (just barely wet!) to “glue” the stripes onto the orange legs, spacing them as you go. Patience is key here; the stripes need to look neat and make those legs really pop up visually. It’s a bit of a process, but it’s so worth the wow factor.

Step 2: Shape the Black Fondant Shoes

Next, knead more CMC into the black fondant to make it pliable for shaping little shoes. Roll into 2cm balls and then form each into short sausages. Pinch one end to form a heel and curl the opposite end into a fancy point—the classic witch shoe silhouette. You can use a small tool or just your finger to make the opening where the leg will go. Then lightly dampen the inside, attach to the orange leg, and set them upright for drying overnight. This part takes some practice, but I promise you’ll get quicker and the results are irresistibly charming.

Step 3: Bake the Deep Black Cocoa Cake

Preheat your oven to 170℃ and prep a 9-inch square pan by greasing and flouring it well. Cream together the butter and sugar until fluffy—this lightens the cake and makes it tender. Beat the eggs in two at a time for even mixing. In a separate bowl, whisk together your dry ingredients including black cocoa and baking powder before sifting them into the butter mixture in batches, alternating with milk. Fold in vanilla last. Bake for about 45-50 minutes but start testing at 40—insert a skewer in, and when it comes out clean, you’re golden! Let it cool completely before you try to slice because warm cake can crumble easily.

Step 4: Whip Up Electric Green Buttercream

To make the buttercream, soften butter until it’s creamy and easy to whip. Add powdered sugar gradually, mixing a little before using your electric mixer to avoid a sugar cloud explosion. Then blend in vanilla and a few drops of electric green food coloring—start small, and add more if needed to get that glowing witches’ brew look. If it seems too stiff, a tablespoon or two of milk or cream loosens the texture perfectly.

Step 5: Assemble Your Halloween Cake Jars

After levelling your cake layers, use a round cutter the size of your jars to cut out cake circles—nine from each layer. Start each jar by dropping sprinkles at the bottom (this also fills in uneven jar bases!). Then layer cake, pipe buttercream from sides to center, add more sprinkles on the sides, top with another cake circle, and finish with a large swirl of bright green buttercream. Sprinkle generously on top, then poke two holes in the buttercream with a skewer and add your witch legs. Doesn’t that just feel like a mini Halloween party in a jar?

How to Serve Witches Brew Halloween Cake Jars Recipe

Garnishes

I love topping these cake jars with colorful sprinkles—you get juicy pops of color through the glass, and they add a fun crunch to each bite. Sometimes I add tiny edible glitter or candy eyeballs for a quirky touch that kids adore. The witch legs aren’t just decoration; they invite everyone to reach in and have a playful moment with their dessert.

Side Dishes

These cake jars are a sweet treat on their own, but if you’re having a whole Halloween spread, they pair beautifully with light bites like spiced apple cider, candied nuts, or caramel popcorn. I like serving them alongside pumpkin soup or autumn-themed charcuterie for a fun, seasonal vibe.

Creative Ways to Present

For a Halloween party, I arranged these jars on a black tiered cake stand surrounded by dry ice fog for a witchy cauldron effect (super dramatic!). You could also tie small recycled jars with orange and black ribbons or nestle them in a hay bale centerpiece for outdoor spooky charm.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Keep your assembled cake jars refrigerated in airtight containers. I find they stay moist and fresh for up to three days. If you plan on enjoying them the next day, just make sure to cover them well to prevent the fondant legs from drying out.

Freezing

I’ve frozen the cake layers without any fuss—wrap them tightly in plastic wrap and foil. The fondant legs don’t freeze well, so make those fresh before assembly. When ready, thaw cake layers overnight in the fridge before building your jars.

Reheating

I usually serve this cake cold but if you want to warm a slice, microwave a piece (without fondant) for about 10 seconds—just enough to soften but not melt your gorgeous green buttercream. The jars themselves aren’t meant for heating.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

Honestly, this Witches Brew Halloween Cake Jars Recipe quickly became one of my favorite Halloween projects because it’s part baking, part crafting, and all fun. It’s such a cool way to impress friends and family with something homemade that feels extra special yet approachable. Whether you’re a fondant pro or a beginner eager to try, you’ll enjoy how these jars come together and become the talk of your spooky celebration. So go ahead, grab your fondants and whip up some bewitching treats—you won’t regret it!

Print