Melted Witch Cookies Recipe

If you’re anything like me and absolutely adore Halloween treats that are both festive and fun to make, then you are going to fall head over heels for this Melted Witch Cookies Recipe. Not only are these little witch hats and brooms adorable, but the combination of peanut butter cookies with chocolate and crunchy snacks creates a flavor and texture combo that’s just downright irresistible. Stick around because I’ll walk you through every step to make sure your batch turns out perfectly magical!

this …

Ingredients You’ll Need

This recipe brilliantly balances the rich, nutty flavor of peanut butter cookies with the bittersweet taste of cocoa candy melts and the crunch of Bugles and pretzels. Shopping for these ingredients is a breeze — the key is to have good-quality candy melts and fresh snacks for the best results.

• Betty Crocker™ peanut butter cookie mix: The base for these cookies; using a good quality mix makes for soft, chewy cookies every time.
• Vegetable oil: Helps keep the cookies moist without overpowering flavor.
• Water: Needed to bring the mix together into dough.
• Egg: Acts as a binder for the cookie dough and adds richness.
• Bugles® snacks: These act as the witch hat bodies; their shape is perfect and adds a nice salty crunch.
• Light cocoa candy melts: Melt these down to coat the Bugles and frost the cookies for that classic witchy look.
• Pretzel sticks: Broken in half, these become the broomsticks—a fun and salty detail.
• Whole wheat cereal biscuit: Crushed to mimic broom bristles; adds a bit of rustic texture and fiber.

Variations

If you love putting your own spin on recipes like I do, this Melted Witch Cookies Recipe is a great canvas for creativity. Whether you need diet-friendly swaps or want a seasonal twist, it’s easy to customize.

• Nut-free variation: Replace peanut butter cookie mix with a nut-free cookie base, and swap peanut butter flavoring with vanilla or cinnamon to avoid allergies.
• Chocolate delight: Add mini chocolate chips into the cookie dough for extra chocolatey goodness; my family goes crazy for the extra melty bits.
• Seasonal toppings: Try crushed pumpkin seeds or colored sprinkles on the broomsticks for fall-themed flair.
• Gluten-free twist: Use a gluten-free cookie mix and gluten-free snacks to keep the holiday spirit alive for everyone at your table.

How to Make Melted Witch Cookies Recipe

Step 1: Mix Up the Perfect Peanut Butter Dough

Start by heating your oven to 375°F. In a large bowl, stir together the Betty Crocker peanut butter cookie mix, vegetable oil, water, and egg. You’ll want to keep stirring until you get a soft, pliable dough — it should be tacky but not sticky. I always find it helps to use a sturdy spoon or my hands to really bring it together. When the dough’s ready, drop tablespoons rounded up onto ungreased cookie sheets, spacing them about 2 inches apart so they have room to spread.

Step 2: Bake and Cool Your Cookies

Bake the cookies for 9 to 11 minutes or until you see they’re set but still soft — don’t overbake or the cookies will get too crisp. Let them cool on the sheets for about a minute before transferring them to wire racks to cool completely. This waiting part is important because it makes frosting and decorating easier and keeps your cookies from breaking.

Step 3: Coat Those Bugles and Get Ready to Decorate

While your cookies cool, line a cookie sheet with waxed paper. Melt the light cocoa candy melts according to the package instructions—if they start to thicken too much, just gently reheat them to keep them smooth and glossy. Dip each Bugle snack into the melted candy and gently tap off excess. Place the coated Bugles on the waxed paper and pop them in the fridge until they’re firm to the touch. This step creates your witches’ hats, and patience here pays off with a beautiful finish.

Step 4: Assemble Your Witches

Reheat the remaining candy melts if needed, then use them to frost each cookie with a generous layer, spreading it to look like a puddle—that’s the witch’s cloak! While the candy is still sticky, press half a pretzel stick onto each cookie for the broom handle. Then sprinkle crushed shredded cereal biscuit right at the base of the pretzel so it looks like broom bristles. Now for the finishing touch! Dip the wide end of each chocolate-coated Bugle in melted candy and stand it upright in the center of each cookie to form the witch’s hat. Let them set completely before moving—if you’re anything like me, that’s the hardest part.

How to Serve Melted Witch Cookies Recipe

Garnishes

I love sprinkling a little extra crushed cereal or cocoa powder around the cookies on a serving plate to add a bit of drama and make them look even more enchanted. Sometimes I add edible glitter or Halloween-themed sprinkles on top of the frosting for parties—everyone howls with delight at those little touches!

Side Dishes

Since these cookies are sweet with a hint of salty crunch, I like serving them with simple sides like a cold glass of milk or hot cocoa with whipped cream. They’re also fantastic alongside fruit slices, which provide a fresh balance to the richness of the candy and cookie.

Creative Ways to Present

For Halloween parties, I’ve set these cookies on black or purple serving trays surrounded by spider-web napkins and little plastic spiders for extra spook factor. Another fun idea: arrange them in a circle to resemble a witch’s cauldron bubbling over—kids love the storytelling aspect!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

I store leftover Melted Witch Cookies in an airtight container at room temperature. They usually stay fresh and chewy for up to three days, although to be honest, mine rarely last that long—everyone wants more! If the candy gets a bit soft, a quick pop in the fridge can help firm them back up.

Freezing

If you want to make these in advance, you can freeze the fully assembled cookies in a single layer on a baking sheet first, then transfer them to a freezer-safe container. Just be sure to separate layers with parchment to prevent sticking. When you thaw them, do so at room temperature for best texture.

Reheating

Since these are best enjoyed fresh, I usually don’t reheat them, but if the cookies have firmed up too much in the fridge, warming them for a few seconds in the microwave (about 10 seconds) brings back their soft, chewy magic. Just watch carefully so you don’t melt the candy decorations!

FAQs

Final Thoughts

This Melted Witch Cookies Recipe has become a personal favorite not just because it’s delicious but because it brings so much joy to the kitchen. My kids and I love how crafting the little witches really sparks our creativity—it’s more than just baking; it’s a fun family tradition. If you’re looking for a festive, unique treat that’s sure to impress and satisfy, give this a try. Trust me, you’ll be casting a delicious spell on everyone who tries them!

Print