Small Batch Gooey Monster Eye Cookies (Flourless, High Protein) Recipe

Hey there! If you’re craving a fun, festive, and downright delicious treat that’s quick to whip up, you’ve stumbled upon a gem. I’m super excited to share my Small Batch Gooey Monster Eye Cookies (Flourless, High Protein) Recipe with you. These cookies aren’t your average sweets—they’re flourless, packed with protein, and come with a quirky monster eye twist that’s perfect for anytime you want a treat that’s both playful and satisfying. Trust me, once you try these, you’ll wonder why you ever made regular cookies any other way!

this …

Ingredients You’ll Need

The ingredients in this recipe blend together effortlessly, giving you a rich, gooey cookie that’s surprisingly filling. I love how the beef isolate protein powder adds muscle-friendly protein without messing with the flavor or texture. And the oats bring just enough chewiness to balance everything out.

• Chocolate grass fed beef isolate protein powder: The star ingredient for that high-protein benefit and subtle chocolate flavor.
• Gluten free oats: Adds texture and makes the cookies naturally gluten-free.
• Baking powder: Helps the cookies rise a bit for a lighter bite.
• Salt: Balances the sweetness and enhances all the flavors.
• Natural peanut butter: Look for creamy and well-stirred for smooth mixing and great flavor.
• Maple syrup: A natural sweetener that keeps these cookies moist and gooey.
• Almond milk: Keeps the batter moist without overpowering taste.
• Vanilla extract: Adds depth and warmth to the cookie flavor.
• Chocolate chips: Because who doesn’t love melty chocolate in cookies?
• M&M type candies: Great for that colorful crunch and to up the fun factor.
• Candy eyeballs: The quirky monster eyes that give these cookies their personality.
• Sprinkles: For extra decoration flair and a bit of texture.

Variations

I love that this Small Batch Gooey Monster Eye Cookies (Flourless, High Protein) Recipe is incredibly versatile. I often mix up the add-ins depending on what I have on hand or the vibe of the day. Get creative and make it yours!

• Nut-free Variation: I’ve swapped peanut butter for sunflower seed butter, and it still works beautifully for those with allergies.
• Vegan Adaptation: Use a plant-based protein powder and substitute maple syrup for a vegan-friendly sweetener—then double check the candy eyes for no gelatin.
• Extra Chocolate: Sometimes I add a handful of dark chocolate chunks and a sprinkle of cocoa nibs to really satisfy chocolate cravings.
• Spooky Season Flair: Try green or orange sprinkles and Halloween-themed candies to make these monsters party-ready.

How to Make Small Batch Gooey Monster Eye Cookies (Flourless, High Protein) Recipe

Step 1: Mix Your Dry Ingredients Thoroughly

Start by grabbing a mixing bowl and whisk together the chocolate beef isolate protein powder, gluten free oats, baking powder, and salt. I like using a fork here to break up any lumps and get everything evenly combined. This step ensures your cookies bake evenly and get that subtle rise without any weird clumps of protein powder. Just trust me — don’t skip this!

Step 2: Add Wet Ingredients and Stir to a Thick Dough

Next, stir in your natural peanut butter, maple syrup, almond milk, and vanilla extract. I usually let the peanut butter sit at room temperature for a few minutes to stir it into a smooth blend—it mixes so much easier that way. Use a fork again to bring everything together until your batter looks thick and cohesive. It’ll be slightly sticky, kind of like traditional cookie dough but a bit more gooey.

Step 3: Fold in Chocolate Chips and Candy Add-Ins

Here’s where the magic begins: fold in your chocolate chips, sprinkles, and M&M-type candies. These add-ins give each bite bursts of crunch and sweetness, making the cookies so much more exciting. Be gentle but thorough — you want the candy pieces evenly spread without crushing them.

Step 4: Scoop Onto Baking Sheet and Shape Gently

Using an ice cream scoop or cookie scoop, drop three large mounds of dough onto your parchment-lined baking sheet. Give them a little space because while these cookies don’t spread as much as traditional ones, they do soften while baking. Press each mound down gently with your palm or the back of the scoop to help them hold a cookie shape — I found this trick keeps them looking great without turning into little blobs.

Step 5: Bake and Set

Pop the tray into your preheated 350°F oven for 8-10 minutes. You’ll know they’re done when the edges are golden and the tops feel set but still soft. If they seem a bit undercooked when you take them out, pop them in the fridge for 5 minutes instead of baking longer — this helps them firm up perfectly without drying out.

Step 6: Decorate with Monster Eyes and Sprinkles

The final, fun step: immediately after baking, press the candy eyeballs into the tops of the warm cookies. I like to arrange the eyes in pairs to give each cookie a silly monster face. Add a few more sprinkles or candies for extra personality. These cookies become real showstoppers with just a little decorating!

How to Serve Small Batch Gooey Monster Eye Cookies (Flourless, High Protein) Recipe

Garnishes

I keep the garnishes simple but fun: extra sprinkles, a handful of mini M&Ms, or even a drizzle of melted dark chocolate. These add a festive pop and look adorable for parties or just a casual snack session.

Side Dishes

If I’m serving these cookies as a treat after a meal, I like pairing them with something light like fresh fruit slices or a dollop of Greek yogurt, which complements the protein-packed cookie nicely without feeling too heavy.

Creative Ways to Present

For Halloween or themed parties, I’ve arranged these monster eye cookies on a black platter scattered with edible glitter or fake spider webs to amp up the spooky vibe. They’re also great stacked in a clear jar with fun ribbon, making a cute cookie gift!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

I store leftover cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 2 days. Because they’re flourless and packed with moisture, they stay soft and gooey much longer than you’d expect. Just make sure the container is sealed well, or they might dry out.

Freezing

Freezing? Totally doable! I freeze the baked cookies in a single layer on a baking sheet, then transfer them to a freezer bag. They keep well up to 3 months. When you’re ready, just thaw at room temperature and add fresh candy eyeballs before serving.

Reheating

To reheat leftovers, I pop them in the microwave for just 10-15 seconds to bring back the gooey softness. Avoid heating too long or they could become dry. You can add a couple of new candy eyes afterward if the originals have softened or slid off.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

I absolutely love how this Small Batch Gooey Monster Eye Cookies (Flourless, High Protein) Recipe turns out every time—it’s one of those rare recipes that feel indulgent without the guilt. Whether you’re making it for a cozy treat, a kid-friendly party, or just a quick protein boost, you’ll find these cookies hit all the right notes of gooey, sweet, and fun. I hope you enjoy baking (and eating!) them as much as I do, and I can’t wait to hear how your monster cookies turn out. Happy baking, friend!

Print